Brian S. McCarville

As a Civil Rights Leader/Advocate and a Court Observer, on multiple occasions, I have observed this judge been extremely bias against non-represented litigants. He regularly intimidates them in his courtroom; and denies them their to argue and defend their cases, thereby infringing on their due process and equal rights protection under the US and California Constitutions.

I was Judge McCarville's Pre Trial and Trial Deputy Public Defender for a number of years. Only have good things to say about him.

CA37989 so obvious

Judge McCarville is the most bias judge I have ever encountered. I have been in practice for 15 years and I have never experienced the type of prejudice from a Judge in my life. He doesn't understand complex contract-real estate cases. He spent the entire time my case was in front of him talking about his "capitol murder" trial. He didn't research the law, made split second unjustified opinions and openly berated me and my co-counsel in Court and then took it back after he realized he was wrong. He needs to hurry up and retire so a more competent judge can take his place. If you are a lawyer who represents a person of color in his Courtroom, do yourself a favor and 170.6 him immediately. I promise you, he will not be fair or follow the law.