Gary Nadler

Pretend-folksy, unpredictable, unprofessional demeanor. Does not read pleadings, shows up unprepared thinking he can “wing it”. Makes serious mistakes, then becomes flippant. Somehow managed to issue separate, contradictory rulings - one for plaintiff and one for defendant! When it became obvious that he was heading for a judicial review panel, he dumped the work on litigants’ attorneys asking them to figure out a way to correct his errors. The case eventually got resolved in my favor, but not until another judge took over. His clerk was just as incompetent.

Cold hearted. Uninformed. Pompous. Unable to admit when making mistake. Courtroom manner is abominable.

The Judge’s behavior was so egregious that his ruling was a proximate cause of my husband’s suicide just hours after Judge’s unfair ruling. He was presented a fact filled case, backed up by very strong evidence. He obviously did not read the pleadings, and ruled in favor of a criminal who only appeared by phone. This was a plea for Elder Abuse protection which was denied. Unfair.

The Judge’s behavior was so egregious that his ruling was a proximate cause of my husband’s suicide just hours after Judge’s unfair ruling. He was presented a fact filled case, backed up by very strong evidence. He obviously did not read the pleadings, and ruled in favor of a criminal who only appeared by phone. This was a plea for Elder Abuse protection which was denied. Unfair.