James V. Selna

District Court

CaliforniaCalifornia Central District Court9th Circuit
3.7/ 5

3 reviews

Courtroom conduct4.0
Impartiality4.0
Case preparation4.0
Case management3.3
Quality of rulings3.7
Treatment of counsel3.7
Empathy with parties3.7
Language & clarity3.7

Get notified when a new review is published

Have you had an experience with this judge? Review and get your reward

Reviews (3)

Old school but good

3.0
/ 5

Good judge. He issued a complex tentative order on a civil case I was handling, and changed a key part of his tentative after oral argument. He is getting old, but he absolutely listened and understood oral argument on a relatively complex issue. Tolerated multiple summary judgment motions on different defendants. Never gives continuances of trial dates after the initial scheduling order. Set a pretty short timetable for a case with international discovery. He's old-school. Gracious from the bench even though his local rules (e.g. an order saying "thou shalt never tap the lectern during oral argument" suggest he's a martinet. Evenhanded: he clearly is attempting to find the right answer. I'd be pleased to get him assigned to any complex commercial case I have.

AnónimoLegal Professional

If there was a negative score I would give it to him.

3.0
/ 5

If there was a negative score I would give it to him. Judge Selna is purely in the pockets of the FTC! We had a rock solid case with all the merits and he only rubber stamps everything the FTC turned in.. even threw out bank records belonging to my corporation that proved all funds went to the proper parties.. he destroyed our lives with his inability to just read the motions and do his job! Costs us millions and allowed the FTC to play dirty, lie and mislead the court. He is as disgraceful as the FTC..

AnónimoLitigant

I tried a complex jury trial before him right before Covid.

5.0
/ 5

I tried a complex jury trial before him right before Covid. I found him to be a thoughtful, hard-working and scholarly judge who strikes a good balance between letting you try your case and keeping out irrelevant or prejudicial evidence. He's phlegmatic and can be hard to read, so you can't always tell if he's getting your points -- but he is. Judge Selna is a former big firm partner and was a Bush appointee, but that background seems to play no role in his decisions, which are right down the middle and based on the law. I certainly didn't win every ruling and I'm not sure he liked me, but I would take Judge Selna again in a heartbeat. Bottom line: he tries hard to be fair, and is. You're lucky to draw him.

AnónimoLawyer