Old school but good
Good judge. He issued a complex tentative order on a civil case I was handling, and changed a key part of his tentative after oral argument. He is getting old, but he absolutely listened and understood oral argument on a relatively complex issue. Tolerated multiple summary judgment motions on different defendants. Never gives continuances of trial dates after the initial scheduling order. Set a pretty short timetable for a case with international discovery. He's old-school. Gracious from the bench even though his local rules (e.g. an order saying "thou shalt never tap the lectern during oral argument" suggest he's a martinet. Evenhanded: he clearly is attempting to find the right answer. I'd be pleased to get him assigned to any complex commercial case I have.