Janis Lynn Sammartino

District

CaliforniaCalifornia Southern District Court9th Circuit
3.8/ 5

4 reviews

Courtroom conduct3.8
Impartiality3.8
Case preparation3.8
Case management3.8
Quality of rulings3.8
Treatment of counsel3.8
Empathy with parties3.8
Language & clarity3.8
Have you had an experience with this judge? Leave your review

Reviews (4)

Criminal Defense Lawyer: She is very nice and pleasant. She is just not very bright. Will give…

2.0
/ 5

She is very nice and pleasant. She is just not very bright. Will give whatever sentence Government wants.

Anónimo

Criminal Defense Lawyer: Had a lengthy trial with Judge Sammartino and found her to be very fair…

5.0
/ 5

Had a lengthy trial with Judge Sammartino and found her to be very fair and patient. Let me try my case. Regardless of how her rulings went, I always felt that she gave everyone a chance and considered my arguments fully before ruling. Extremely polite to counsel and a pleasure to work with I think.

Anónimo

Criminal Defense Lawyer: She's relatively new, but has quickly established herself as one of the…

5.0
/ 5

She's relatively new, but has quickly established herself as one of the best judges in the district. She is very evenhanded -- I've won and lost in cases before her, but her rulings are always intelligent and well considered. In one case, she issued a written opinion that were better than the parties' briefs. She also is patient and respectful to Defendants. I always look forward to appearing in her court.

Anónimo

Criminal Defense Lawyer: Judge Sammartino has a very nice demeanor. She will listen to arguments…

3.0
/ 5

Judge Sammartino has a very nice demeanor. She will listen to arguments in a very respectful way and she does not rush the parties unnecessarily. Unfortunately, she is not very bright and she is very pro-Government. She does not know the Rules of Evidence. She is a nightmare in trial because of it.

Anónimo