Karen B. Rothenberg

Supreme Court

New YorkRichmond (Staten Island)New York
1.0/ 5

2 reviews

Courtroom conduct1.0
Impartiality1.0
Case preparation1.0
Case management1.0
Quality of rulings1.0
Treatment of counsel1.0
Empathy with parties1.0
Language & clarity1.0

Get notified when a new review is published

Have you had an experience with this judge? Review and get your reward

Reviews (2)

Disrespectful and racist.

1.0
/ 5

Disrespectful and racist. Favors developers over the "small man". Incompetent and without heart. Will be happy when she is no longer on the bench

AnónimoLawyer

For a person with such an interesting and qualified background, it is unfortunate that for all that, Judge Rothenberg...

1.0
/ 5

For a person with such an interesting and qualified background, it is unfortunate that for all that, Judge Rothenberg does not appear to follow the law. Her opinions in my experience are short, off based and clearly intended to favor one side. I have only dealt with her on a few discovery and motion practice issues so she could be better in other areas but in my experience, Judge Rothenberg has no compunction flouting the law with little to no articulated rationale. This attorney urges that Judge Rothenberg never be considered for a higher court. She is precisely the sort of judge whom the appellate courts are designed to constrain.

AnónimoLawyer