Paul I. Marx

Supreme Court

New YorkPutnamNew York
1.8/ 5

6 reviews

Courtroom conduct1.8
Impartiality1.8
Case preparation1.8
Case management1.8
Quality of rulings1.8
Treatment of counsel1.8
Empathy with parties1.8
Language & clarity1.8

Get notified when a new review is published

Have you had an experience with this judge? Review and get your reward

Reviews (6)

Wannabe tough guy who thinks he’s intelligent.

1.0
/ 5

Wannabe tough guy who thinks he’s intelligent. Unfortunately for him, he is neither tough nor smart. He is arrogant, lazy, an incompetent. He was a horrible plaintiff’s attorney so it makes sense he is an incompetent judge. An absolute embarrassment. [Redacted by ed.]

AnónimoLawyer

Relatively typical state court nonsense.

1.0
/ 5

Relatively typical state court nonsense. Intellectually lazy, pro-plaintiff, and ill-tempered at times. Prepare accordingly.

AnónimoLawyer

Judge marx declare that I was unable to handle the divorce so he provided me with a chaperone: The chaperone was note...

1.0
/ 5

Judge marx declare that I was unable to handle the divorce so he provided me with a chaperone: The chaperone was noted for embezzlement in Yonkers school district,. my husband threatened me that I would not be allowed to go to my daughter‘s wedding if I asked for his pension. Judge marx was nasty to me And very supportive to my husband, despite letters coming from my friends and doctors how unfair this was to me.

AnónimoLawyer

The other comments about Justice Marx must have come from disgruntled lawyers who lost their cases or motions.

4.0
/ 5

The other comments about Justice Marx must have come from disgruntled lawyers who lost their cases or motions. My experience has been different. Justice Marx expects counsel to be prompt and well-prepared. If that is too much of a burden, perhaps the complainer needs to find a less demanding area of law to practice. I have not detected any bias. To the contrary, I have found this judge to be focused on, and receptive to, cogent arguments and admissible evidence.

AnónimoLawyer

The worst. Should not be any kind of judge.

2.0
/ 5

The worst. Should not be any kind of judge.

AnónimoLitigant

The most unprofessional Judge in all of the lower Hudson Valley.

2.0
/ 5

The most unprofessional Judge in all of the lower Hudson Valley. Nasty for no reason, condescending and inappropriate comments on the record to make himself feel better. He was a former plaintiff attorney (bad one too) who now sits on his throne and single handedly lowers the esteem of the judicial profession. An embarrassment to his fellow colleagues. Good riddance in just a few short years.

AnónimoLawyer