Penney S. Azcarate

Circuit

FairfaxFairfax19th Circuit
4.0/ 5

54 reviews

Courtroom conduct4.0
Impartiality4.0
Case preparation4.0
Case management4.0
Quality of rulings4.0
Treatment of counsel4.0
Empathy with parties4.0
Language & clarity4.0

Get notified when a new review is published

Have you had an experience with this judge? Review and get your reward

Reviews (54)

What can I say, best judge ever, so glad she was fair though I wished Amber didn’t get anything at the end, felt like...

5.0
/ 5

What can I say, best judge ever, so glad she was fair though I wished Amber didn’t get anything at the end, felt like they wanted not to just leave her out, 2mil for what? For destroying man’s life? I wish she didn’t take anything as it all was lies but hey, at least Johnny got the justice he deserved, the judge was fair, strong and very professional, kudos to you judge and thanks for the hard work.

AnónimoLegal Professional

To the people who continue to rate this judge based on the high profile case, get over yourselves.

5.0
/ 5

To the people who continue to rate this judge based on the high profile case, get over yourselves. She conducted herself in the most patient and professional way possible during the entire case. Unlike Heard, and her lawyers who were an absolute trainwreck nightmare to deal with. Their entire case was hearsay. If you had watched the entire case from start to finish on YouTube for FREE mind you, and not from deranged one sided “Believe all females nomatter what even when there’s EVIDENCE proving otherwise” TikTok clips.. you’d clearly see that the Jury’s ruling’s were spot on. The jury decided this case, not the judge. Y’all stay mad, cause it’s embarrassing you continue to come here and grasp straws this way. You weren’t in the court, stop selecting court staff etc, that’s what “other” is for. Move on.

AnónimoLegal Professional

What an excellant judge, I enjoyed this case though I felt really bad for johnny, but thankfully he came out on top a...

5.0
/ 5

What an excellant judge, I enjoyed this case though I felt really bad for johnny, but thankfully he came out on top and won the case, truth always wins, and lies always get revealed.

AnónimoLegal Professional

Ty judge for doing an excellent job, please do not care for heard comments, we can see she hired some bots to comment...

5.0
/ 5

Ty judge for doing an excellent job, please do not care for heard comments, we can see she hired some bots to comment here, can’t believe she didn’t stop doing this old game till now, nothing will change the truth, she lied about everything, Ty judge, all my respect.

AnónimoLegal Professional

Excellent judge, she was fair, firm, and she took things well in hands, tbh I was worried at first she won’t be a fai...

5.0
/ 5

Excellent judge, she was fair, firm, and she took things well in hands, tbh I was worried at first she won’t be a fair judge but she proved me wrong, the trial was amazing I watch it again and again believe it or not, excellent work judge.

AnónimoLegal Professional

So, it would seem that, even now, the Depp simps are wrongly portraying Azcarate the incompetent as being fair & impa...

5.0
/ 5

So, it would seem that, even now, the Depp simps are wrongly portraying Azcarate the incompetent as being fair & impartial, even when she had no jurisdiction to oversee the trial. Technically, it should have happened in California, as that's where Amber lived, but the Depp simps don't realize that the location of a newspaper's servers are a non-factor in legal matters. And, they're STILL mad that Depp invalidated his lawsuit by accepting $1 million from Amber's insurance; Travelers wouldn't pay out if there's malice.

AnónimoLegal Professional

So, as it turns out, Azcarate the Incompetent is guilty of judicial malpractice.

5.0
/ 5

So, as it turns out, Azcarate the Incompetent is guilty of judicial malpractice. Honestly, if the trial is ever investigated, and it's found that she erred in presiding over it, pretty sure she could face removal from the bench & even disbarment. Also, for the Depp simps talking about watching it on YouTube, they conveniently omit about how they did so through completely biased legal hacks.

AnónimoLegal Professional

Judge Penney did an excellent job in the Depp vs.

5.0
/ 5

Judge Penney did an excellent job in the Depp vs. Heard case despite what these spammers and children via tik tok say. I watched the entire trial from start to finish, and she was beyond fair and PATIENT will all the dramatics. Watch the trial and see for yourself, it’s on YouTube.

AnónimoLegal Professional

The way this judge carried out the law and the trial was straightforward.

5.0
/ 5

The way this judge carried out the law and the trial was straightforward. She she carried out the law to the best that I have seen in most courts of the size.

AnónimoLegal Professional

Honestly, hearing about how Azcarate the Incompetent mishandled the trial, she needs to lose the upcoming election, t...

1.0
/ 5

Honestly, hearing about how Azcarate the Incompetent mishandled the trial, she needs to lose the upcoming election, then face prosecution for judicial misconduct. In fact, Amber should sue her for judicial malpractice, and show the brainless Deppheads that their "idol" IS nothing more than a domestic abuser & a wife beater. The careers of Azcarate, Vasquez, Chew, & even Depp need to end for the suffering Heard was put through. History WILL remember all four of them as low-life scum.

AnónimoLawyer

Sad to hear we're now finding out the Dishonorable Azcarate presided over the Depp v.

1.0
/ 5

Sad to hear we're now finding out the Dishonorable Azcarate presided over the Depp v. Heard defamation trial in a way that no honorable judge would ever dare try. As multiple credible lawyers have stated, the trial never should have been allowed to happen in Virginia, since there was no jurisdictional relationship there. Hopefully, when Amber is allowed to tell her truth, it'll end not just the acting career of Depp, but the legal careers of Azcarate, Vasquez, Chew, & hopefully even shut down Brown Rudnick.

AnónimoLawyer

Such a wonderful demeanor.

5.0
/ 5

Such a wonderful demeanor. Kind thoughtful and even keeled at all time. Above all fair.

AnónimoLawyer

So, if what I've heard is correct, because of Depp agreeing to the settlement, he practically saved the legal careers...

1.0
/ 5

So, if what I've heard is correct, because of Depp agreeing to the settlement, he practically saved the legal careers of Ratmille, Ben Chewin' My Ass, & the Dishonorable Azcarate. If he would have let Amber's appeal go through, she very likely would have succeeded in getting the jury's verdict vacated, which would have proved that Vasquez, Chew, & Azcarate truly are legal hacks that don't deserve to work in the legal field. But, since Amber's free to tell her side of the story, she still may be able to help retire those three legal hacks from their industry, while also proving his groupies as nothing more than blind, ignorant sheep.

AnónimoLawyer

So, if what I've read from prominent lawyers on Twitter is true, then Depp may have saved the legal careers of the Di...

1.0
/ 5

So, if what I've read from prominent lawyers on Twitter is true, then Depp may have saved the legal careers of the Dishonorable Azcarate, Ratmille, & Ben Chewin' My Ass. If Amber's appeal had been allowed to go through with, the Virginia jury's verdict would have been vacated, and that would have killed the legal careers of Azcarate, Vasquez, & Chew. It's only because Depp knew he would lose the appeal that he ended up agreeing to the settlement which still ended up rendering the jury's verdict essentially non-existent. But, here's still to hoping that Virginia voters will keep the settlement in mind when they vote to kick the Dishonorable Azcarate off the bench. Hell, maybe she can go work as a judicial consultant for Fox News before they get shut down thanks to Smartmatic & Dominion. Azcarate is a hack judge & Vasquez & Chew are hack lawyers. Here's to hoping that NBC suffers through severe viewership & ratings plummet before they realise hiring Vasquez as a legal expert was one of the biggest mistakes that company has ever made.

AnónimoLawyer

Aww, apparently, the Deppies STILL can't get over Depp & Heard's settlement rendering the verdict nullified.

5.0
/ 5

Aww, apparently, the Deppies STILL can't get over Depp & Heard's settlement rendering the verdict nullified. Can't wait for the Dishonorable Azcarate to lose her re-election for Virginia judge. And, apparently, the Deppies also don't understand that juries don't understand domestic violence & spousal abuse. And, seems the Deppies like making stuff up about Heard's insurance providers suing her, since if that was true, we'd be hearing about it. So, continue believing the lie that she's being sued by insurance & that Australia is investigating her. Maybe it'll finally stick in your thick skulls if Depp's cronies on Twitter are eventually sued for defamation for the lies they've put forth. Honestly, at this point, the anti-Amber people are exposing themselves as idiots & intentional liars, just like their "idol". So, continue spewing your lie-filled words; it won't help Depp when he can no longer find work in Hollywood, while Amber witnesses her big comeback. Oh, and can't wait to see NBC's ratings & viewership drop like a lead balloon now that they've hired Ratmille as a legal analyst. No surprise, since she got the job through connections, instead of talent (which she has none of).

AnónimoLegal Professional

Judge Azcarate was fair and thorough, anyone saying otherwise didn’t watch the trial in full.

5.0
/ 5

Judge Azcarate was fair and thorough, anyone saying otherwise didn’t watch the trial in full. It’s childish to think leaving your off topic comments and vengeful inaccurate spam ratings are going to do anything. This isn’t a forum, no one wants to hear your whining. Go back to Twitter. Additionally, the Jury was spot on in their decision making process. If you lie on the stand, people see right through that. That’s what happened multiple times while she was on the stand. She damaged her own case. Justice was served, and truth always wins. Aside from her settling, Amber Heard’s insurance companies are suing her.. on top of that she committed perjury in 3 countries. Anyone still blindly defending her is defending her because she made a mockery of the me two movement, and because of that.. going back on that would make the movement look worse than it already does. The more people defend her the more it goes to show you it’s not about finding out the truth for them.. it’s to believe all women no matter what even if they lied and committed multiple acts of abuse themselves on NUMEROUS people. It’s pathetic, and the majority of people saw right through all of it. Once the investigation in Australia is complete (fast approaching and only a matter of time) she will be tried for Perjury there first. She created these problems for herself. Between the lawsuits from the insurance companies and her own acts of perjury - she only has herself to blame for her own undoing. No matter what legal team she would have hired, lies have a way of catching up to you and coming out. We all got to see first hand how she tried to poorly cover her lies up, and it all came out in the end.

AnónimoLegal Professional

So, apparently, Depp the Abuser's fans don't understand how the law works.

1.0
/ 5

So, apparently, Depp the Abuser's fans don't understand how the law works. The settlement Depp & Heard agreed to states neither defamed the other, thereby legally overruling the incompetent jury's verdict; if anything, after reading the amicus brief from Heard & her legal team, Jawny & his loser lawyers realized she'd win the appeal, thereby ruining Depp, so Vasquez & Chew convinced Depp to agree to the settlement. I mean, if Depp thought he'd win the appeal, then why did he sign the settlement? Also, the fact that Heard didn't have to admit guilt, and isn't bound by a gag order/NDA, Depp's fans are the Trumpers of the entertainment world. Just like how Trump eventually lost, so did Depp. BTW: do the Depp fans realize that Bullshit Rednecks stated in their press release that, even if Heard talks about the case, Depp can't do shit, because he agreed not to take any further action or re-take previous actions? So, in other words, Ratmille & Ben Chewin' My Ass won't even admit the truth to Depp & his fans.

AnónimoLawyer

Sorry forgot to leave my rating, amazing and respectable judge.

5.0
/ 5

Sorry forgot to leave my rating, amazing and respectable judge.

AnónimoLawyer

Ty judge for your fairness in court, the I was worried at the beginning but finally a fair trial was done, so sorry t...

5.0
/ 5

Ty judge for your fairness in court, the I was worried at the beginning but finally a fair trial was done, so sorry these idiots of Amber Stans are floating the comments with bad ratings, what do you expect? She lost, Johnny won, end of story.

AnónimoLegal Professional

Judge Penny was excellent, she had the patience of a Saint.

5.0
/ 5

Judge Penny was excellent, she had the patience of a Saint. The Amber Fanatics leaving 1 star reviews just goes to show you how petty and pathetic they all really are. As of today, with Heard settling by paying Depp 1 million, the trial stands as it has. She LOST. He won. If she decides to defame him again, she can be taken to court again for defamatory statements that were proven to be false in a court of law. Hands down, Judge Penny is incredible.. it doesn’t matter who the judge would have been in this case, the only way these insane children would be happy is if the world believed AH’s lies. They didn’t. The majority of us saw right through her lies on the witness stand, and through EVIDENCE. Stay mad lunatics.

AnónimoLegal Professional