Philip A. Brimmer

District

ColoradoColorado District Court10th Circuit
2.4/ 5

8 reviews

Courtroom conduct2.4
Impartiality2.4
Case preparation2.4
Case management2.4
Quality of rulings2.4
Treatment of counsel2.4
Empathy with parties2.4
Language & clarity2.4
Have you had an experience with this judge? Leave your review

Reviews (8)

Civil Litigation - Private: Judge Gorsuch was an admirable & honorable choice for Supreme Court…

1.0
/ 5

Judge Gorsuch was an admirable & honorable choice for Supreme Court Justice. That stated, many of our Colorado citizens are thankful that Judge Brimmer was not part of our current selection process for SCOTUS. His willful intent in refusing to honor and respect our Constitution as well as abuse of discretion is reflective in his judicial opinions. Not a judgeship our country should be victimized by any further.

Anónimo

Civil Litigation - Private: It can be proven by way of evidence, and documents from both parties to…

1.0
/ 5

It can be proven by way of evidence, and documents from both parties to the case his extreme bias towards Pro se litigants. This is categorized in his own judicial opinions. While unfortunate, he holds a pattern of disregarding Constitutional law and credible unrefuted documents. Not something we experienced with his father or other judicial members. Very apparent when self representation litigants are involved. No greater threat to our system than that of a judge who refuses to review all facts, law and evidence in a case.

Anónimo

Criminal Defense Lawyer: seems to disfavor pro se litigants in foreclosure matters. Has made…

2.0
/ 5

seems to disfavor pro se litigants in foreclosure matters. Has made some decent opinions except when they involve Colorado foreclosure which do not reflect Supreme Court Colorado rulings as well as some United States Supreme Court rulings.

Anónimo

Other: Could not agree more with a previous comment that Judge Brimmer is…

3.0
/ 5

Could not agree more with a previous comment that Judge Brimmer is extremely biased, not very well competent, and his rulings are flat wrong or conclusory. His own drafted opinion proves this beyond a doubt. Respectfully, he's nothing like his father in any capacity as Judge.

Anónimo

Litigant: I thought Judge Brimmer was an excellent Judge. I was the Plaintiff,…

3.0
/ 5

I thought Judge Brimmer was an excellent Judge. I was the Plaintiff, but I felt this Judge was very fair minded to both sides. He would give thought to a ruling before offering his opinion on a topic. Even if I would have lost I would have thought the Judge was more then fair in my case.

Anónimo

Criminal Defense Lawyer: He's nothing like his father. Extremely biased against the little guy…

1.0
/ 5

He's nothing like his father. Extremely biased against the little guy and really not very competent. Many of his rulings are flat wrong or conclusory.

Anónimo

Civil Litigation - Private: Nice judge, but is quite biased. If the Plaintiff is an individual, and…

3.0
/ 5

Nice judge, but is quite biased. If the Plaintiff is an individual, and the Defendant is a big corporation, he's never seen a Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment that he doesn't like.

Anónimo

Prosecutor: Very bright. Industrious. Knows how to try a case. Rules quickly and…

5.0
/ 5

Very bright. Industrious. Knows how to try a case. Rules quickly and correctly. Great temperment. Will be one of the best trial judges in America. Just like his father, it is a pleasure to try a case in his courtroom.

Anónimo