I had an MSC with him, both parties flew in from out of state.
I had an MSC with him, both parties flew in from out of state. The parties had hit a wall about the amount of money to be paid in settlement. Unfortunately this judge could not read the room and spent an inordinate amount of time talking about the facts with both parties, and telling us we had all morning and afternoon if needed to settle the case. The other party had made a lowball 998 offer and their first offer at the MSC was even lower though the judge never said as much at the time. Instead he declared the case couldn't be settled and dismissed the parties with 2 hours of the morning's MSC left. Literally no settlement offers were exchanged. I knew the other side lowballed us and their counsel admitted as much to me. He thought it was no big deal and so did I, I see cases with larger gaps between the parties settle all the time. Both counsel were baffled by what this judge did. Both parties wasted time and money because of this, and this judge's handling of the MSC. My only guess as to why he did what he did is because he found something better to do and blew us off. Kind of a weaselly thing to do.