Steve McCarthy

Superior Court

ArizonaMaricopaArizona
1.3/ 5

3 reviews

Courtroom conduct1.3
Impartiality1.3
Case preparation1.3
Case management1.3
Quality of rulings1.3
Treatment of counsel1.3
Empathy with parties1.3
Language & clarity1.3

Get notified when a new review is published

Have you had an experience with this judge? Review and get your reward

Reviews (3)

In my case before Judge McCarthy, SUBSTANTIAL evidence was presented regarding ongoing high-conflict co-parenting.

1.0
/ 5

In my case before Judge McCarthy, SUBSTANTIAL evidence was presented regarding ongoing high-conflict co-parenting. This included repeated communication failures and withholding of information, more than 30 instances of unilateral decision-making, involvement of the children in the conflict, consistent negative commentary about the other parent, multiple instances of interference with parenting time, and concerns affecting the children’s medical care, emotional well-being, and documented ongoing substance abuse issues.

Anónimo

Judge McCarthy shows no regard for the law, rules, or merits of a case.

1.0
/ 5

Judge McCarthy shows no regard for the law, rules, or merits of a case. He favors attorneys, ignores evidence, and issues lazy, careless rulings that destroy lives. His disregard for justice and accountability makes him a disgrace to our justice system.

AnónimoLitigant

Very bias. Lacks ability to make logical fair rulings.

2.0
/ 5

Very bias. Lacks ability to make logical fair rulings. Void of integrity and insight. Incompetent to make important decisions regarding the lives of the parties in his court room. Dangerous violations of laws and procedures. Rulings are sloppy and contrary to law. Not fit to be a judge. Worse than Crandall. Complete disregard for the rights of the Unrepresented Disabled population.This is a the option of 22 attorneys with direct experience with Mr McCarthy

AnónimoLawyer