Valerie E. Caproni

District Court

New YorkNew York Southern District Court2nd Circuit
2.8/ 5

8 reviews

Courtroom conduct2.8
Impartiality2.8
Case preparation2.8
Case management2.8
Quality of rulings2.8
Treatment of counsel2.8
Empathy with parties2.8
Language & clarity2.8

Get notified when a new review is published

Have you had an experience with this judge? Review and get your reward

Reviews (8)

Caproni [Redacted by Ed.] has an axe to grind.

1.0
/ 5

Caproni [Redacted by Ed.] has an axe to grind. Its shows in her opinions and orders. We have invested 7-figures to lobby the House and Senate Judiciary to recall this Judge and remove her from the bench. [Redacted by Ed.] . Racists too! But seems she fits right in with the rest of the corrupted judiciary for the Southern District of New York. Do whatever procedurally possible to get a change of venue to the Eastern District or another State.

AnónimoLawyer

In response to comment # 35175, Judge Caproni did not tip the scales to convict; she removed the scales.

3.0
/ 5

In response to comment # 35175, Judge Caproni did not tip the scales to convict; she removed the scales. The evidence to support this is openly available in the record. Unfortunately, the Second Circuit is a pay-per-review-court. Indigents need not apply. Under the law, Judge Caproni should be removed from the bench. [Redacted by Ed.] She and repeatedly and knowingly ignored precedent and the law to convict an innocent defendant.

AnónimoLitigant

Avoid. Correctly calculated that she would be a disaster the minute her name was on the case.

3.0
/ 5

Avoid. Correctly calculated that she would be a disaster the minute her name was on the case. [Redacted by Ed.] This wasteland of a district court reassigned case to her and she "gave it" to a BigLaw magistrate to sit on it for months then dismiss it despite both parties NOT consenting to the magistrate. [Redacted by Ed.] Avoid her at all costs [Redacted]

AnónimoLawyer

I don't think the last comment is appropriate.

3.0
/ 5

I don't think the last comment is appropriate. Yes, she's leans pro government but tipping the scales to convict? I don't think so. Sounds like a disgruntled family member.

AnónimoLawyer

Judge Caproni is very independent.

3.0
/ 5

Judge Caproni is very independent. The Constitution, the law, binding precedent, nor her oath of office will stand in her way when she makes up her mind [Redacted by Ed.].

AnónimoLitigant

Judge Valerie Caproni is a supremely thorough and exceedingly fair jurist!

3.0
/ 5

Judge Valerie Caproni is a supremely thorough and exceedingly fair jurist! Additionally, she is a wonderful person!

AnónimoLegal Professional

She is heavy handed but a fair judge.

3.0
/ 5

She is heavy handed but a fair judge. Her deep experience and fairness make her well suited to handle any case

AnónimoLegal Professional

I've been practicing over 30 years, civil and criminal.

3.0
/ 5

I've been practicing over 30 years, civil and criminal. She is easily one of the top five pieces of [redacted by ed.] that has ever been on the bench. 'nuff said.

AnónimoLawyer