Civil Litigation - Private: Reasonable in scheduling issues. That's where the praise ends. Easily…
3.0
/ 5
Reasonable in scheduling issues. That's where the praise ends. Easily swayed by counsel argument regardless of the law and precedent.
Anónimo
Andrew T. Baxter
Magistrate
New YorkNew York Northern District Court2nd Circuit
3.3/ 5
4 reviews
Courtroom conduct3.3
Impartiality3.3
Case preparation3.3
Case management3.3
Quality of rulings3.3
Treatment of counsel3.3
Empathy with parties3.3
Language & clarity3.3
Have you had an experience with this judge? Leave your review
Reviews (4)
Civil Litigation - Private: He does something no Judge should ever do, he shows a clear preference…
2.0
/ 5
He does something no Judge should ever do, he shows a clear preference for one side without understanding or looking at the facts
Anónimo
Civil Litigation - Private: Very reasonable and respectful of private counsel demands. Sees through…
5.0
/ 5
Very reasonable and respectful of private counsel demands. Sees through puffery by counsel and seeks to get to the core issues quickly.
Anónimo
Civil Litigation - Private: Magistrate Baxter is reasonable with scheduling orders and appreciative…
3.0
/ 5
Magistrate Baxter is reasonable with scheduling orders and appreciative of the needs of private practitioners. He is generally affable and not unduly strict, and generally hits it down the middle, but he tends to show some bias in favor of municipal defendants.
Anónimo